Wholefoods shareholders vote on Amazon takeover

by Molly Johnson-Jones

Amazon’s bid for Wholefoods on June 16th 2017 took investors by surprise.

The idea of Amazon having a bricks-and-mortar food presence seems incongruous with its online model, and its food and grocery initiatives have been small-scale so far.

Yet Wholefoods shareholders are expected to approve the acquisition, and barring any last minute complications, their vote will change the future of global food retail.

But why would Amazon want to purchase the struggling Wholefoods?

The basic motives for the deal are compelling enough. Wholefoods has 466 stores offering an established physical presence which could be used for click and collect; not just for groceries but for Amazon’s full inventory. In return, Amazon will offer Wholefoods an online presence, rather than relying on Instacart, and by cutting these costs will help to boost its profits.

Wholefoods has struggled to remain competitive as shareholders have pushed back on price investment due to concern about profitability, but Amazon is less concerned with profit, preferring to invest in growth and scale.

By investing in prices and taking a temporary hit on profit it can boost Wholefoods’ market share. In the short-term, there probably won’t be a great deal of change – with its other acquisitions, such as Zappos, Amazon tends to give its companies freedom.

However the future appears more exciting, or terrifying if you are an established food retailer. Investors recognized this and Walmart and Kroger shares plummeted upon announcement of the deal. Food retail is a notoriously difficult market to penetrate, as reputation means everything when it comes to consumers’ groceries.

Although Amazon is an established household name, it would likely have taken significantly longer to grow its food retail business from scratch than by acquiring a household name like Wholefoods.

Scale is essential in terms of fulfillment, and growing an online grocery business to a profitable scale would have been more costly, more risky, and taken much longer to gain a foothold in the established US food market. Despite its premium positioning, Wholefoods offers the chance for Amazon to become a serious player in the F&G market very quickly by providing scale and an existing customer base.

Now that Amazon has bypassed much of the hard work it is free to improve and experiment with Wholefoods’ stores and supply chain. Amazon can modernize and transform Wholefoods into a grocery retailer of the future, competing directly with incumbent supermarkets with multiple fulfillment channels. Simultaneously, Amazon can continue to work on its other grocery propositions such as AmazonGo, Amazon Fresh, and Amazon Pantry with the added benefit and risk reduction of having Wholefoods in its portfolio of companies.

Amazon has the spare capital to continue to invest in improving its technology, and given the pressure on supermarket’s margins, now is the best time for it to pull away in terms of competitive advantage. The other grocers won’t want to sacrifice their fragile margins to the same extent, and if we look at Amazon’s grocery pricing history, we know that when the other supermarkets are raising prices it tends to drop them to exploit the opportunity to gain market share.

Although there was some talk of the Federal Trade Commission being notified of potential job losses as a result of the deal, and Trump wanting to look into Amazon’s finances, it is unlikely that there will be any meaningful objections to the deal as it ultimately benefits the consumer and enhances innovation in a rather stagnant market.

Amazon is the ultimate disruptor in retail, but for a long time it has only been on the periphery for the food retailers. The shareholder vote today consolidates the threat of Amazon repeating the damage on the grocery market it has ravaged on mainstream supermarket territory. Amazon’s vision of being a one-stop-shop for all of a consumer’s needs is one step closer to being a reality.

— Molly Johnson-Jones is Senior Analyst at GlobalData.